Back to Meditation

Training attention · Meditation

Learning to Choose Your Thoughts

A compassionate practice for choosing where attention goes without trying to suppress what the mind brings.

10 min read

Learning to Choose Your Thoughts You may not be able to stop every thought that appears. But you can learn that you don’t have to follow every thought that does. We spend an enormous amount of time inside our own minds. Thoughts about what happened yesterday. Thoughts about what might happen tomorrow. Thoughts about what someone said. Thoughts about what we should have said. Thoughts about what we need to do, what we forgot to do, what we wish were different, and what we’re afraid might happen next. Some thoughts are useful. Some are beautiful. Some are completely ridiculous. And some can hurt. One of the things meditation has taught me is that having a thought and choosing to give that thought my attention are not necessarily the same thing. That distinction can create a little freedom. You Don’t Choose Every Thought I think it’s important to begin here. We don’t choose every thought that appears in our minds. A memory can surface without permission. A worry can arrive unexpectedly. An old fear can suddenly make itself known. Sometimes the mind produces something so strange that we wonder where it came from in the first place. That’s being human. So when I talk about learning to choose our thoughts, I don’t mean that we should control every thought that enters our minds. We can’t. And trying to can become exhausting. The practice is different. We can begin learning which thoughts we want to feed with our attention. A Thought Is Not a Command This may be one of the most freeing things we can learn. Just because your mind says something doesn’t mean you have to act on it. I should check my phone. You don’t have to. Everyone is probably judging me. You don’t have to believe it. I need to solve this right now. Maybe you don’t. What if everything goes wrong? You don’t have to spend the next hour trying to prevent an imaginary future. A thought can simply be a thought. It can appear. We can notice it. And we can decide whether it deserves our attention. Notice This is where the first step of Notice, Name, Return becomes so important. Before we can choose differently, we have to notice what is happening. Maybe you realize you’ve been replaying an argument for the tenth time. Maybe you’ve spent twenty minutes imagining a conversation that hasn’t happened. Maybe you’ve been comparing your life to someone else’s. Maybe you’ve been telling yourself a story about what another person thinks of you. Notice. Not with judgment. Just awareness. Oh. This is where my mind is. That realization is already a change. Name Sometimes naming the thought pattern gives us enough distance to see it more clearly. Worry. Comparison. Rehearsing. Remembering. Judging. Catastrophizing. Planning. We don’t have to analyze it. We simply identify what is happening. Naming doesn’t mean that the thought is wrong. It simply means we’re recognizing it rather than being completely absorbed in it. Return Then comes the choice. Where do I want my attention to go now? Maybe you return to your breath. Maybe you return to the person sitting across from you. Maybe you return to the work in front of you. Maybe you return to something meaningful you had been reading. Maybe you simply return to the physical experience of being where you are. This is not forcing the original thought away. It’s choosing not to continue feeding it. And sometimes you’ll have to make that choice again thirty seconds later. That’s okay. That’s practice. Choosing Doesn’t Mean Pretending I think this distinction matters especially when we’re dealing with difficult emotions. Choosing our thoughts does not mean telling ourselves everything is wonderful when it isn’t. We don’t have to turn grief into gratitude before we’re ready. We don’t have to call anger peaceful. We don’t have to tell ourselves we’re fine when we’re hurting. That isn’t mindfulness. We can acknowledge what is real and still choose where we place our attention next. This hurts. That’s real. I’m angry. That’s real. I’m afraid. That’s real. And perhaps alongside those truths, there can eventually be another choice: What do I want to do with my attention now? What We Practice Becomes Familiar Our minds develop habits. If we repeatedly spend our attention worrying, worry can become familiar. If we repeatedly compare ourselves with other people, comparison can become automatic. If we constantly consume outrage, outrage can begin to feel like the natural emotional climate of our lives. This doesn’t mean we caused every difficult thought we’ve ever had. It means attention has patterns. And patterns can be practiced in another direction. This is one reason the training of attention matters so much. We are not simply deciding what to think once. We’re gradually becoming more aware of what we repeatedly return to. The Easwaran Influence This is another place where Eknath Easwaran’s work has influenced the way I think about meditation. His approach emphasizes training attention rather than simply waiting for the mind to become quiet. There is a deliberate quality to the practice: choosing what we give our attention to and returning when the mind wanders. What I take from that isn’t the idea that we should never have negative thoughts. It’s the possibility that attention can become more intentional. We can become more aware of what we’re rehearsing internally. We can notice what repeatedly captures us. And we can begin making different choices about what we dwell on. What Are You Feeding? Imagine your attention as something you feed. Every time you return to a thought, you give it a little more of your energy. Sometimes that’s exactly what we need. A problem deserves attention. A relationship deserves attention. A difficult decision deserves attention. But other times, we’re feeding something simply because it knows how to get our attention. An argument we’ve already had. A fear about something that hasn’t happened. A comparison that always leaves us feeling inadequate. A story about ourselves that we’ve repeated for so long that we’ve forgotten it is a story. We can ask: Is this something I want to keep feeding? Choosing What Matters There are also thoughts worth returning to. The people we love. The work that matters to us. The values we want to live by. The things we’re grateful for. The questions we’re genuinely curious about. The qualities we want to cultivate. The kind of person we want to be when life becomes difficult. Choosing our thoughts isn’t only about moving away from what is unhelpful. It’s also about deliberately returning to what matters. That is where attention becomes something beautiful. You Will Still Have Difficult Thoughts I want to leave room for this. Learning to choose your thoughts doesn’t mean you will suddenly become someone whose mind is always peaceful. You will still worry. You will still get angry. You will still think things you wish you hadn’t thought. You will still have days when your mind feels like it has twelve conversations happening at once. That’s okay. The goal isn’t perfection. The goal is awareness. And perhaps a little more choice. When you notice what is happening, you have an opportunity to decide what happens next. Not every time. Not perfectly. But more often than before. A Small Practice The next time you notice yourself caught in a repetitive thought, pause. Ask yourself: What am I thinking about? What am I feeling? Is this thought useful right now? Where would I rather place my attention? You don’t need to force an answer. Notice. Name. Return. And if the thought comes back, return again. This isn’t about winning an argument with your own mind. It’s about becoming more intentional about where you spend your attention. You Are Not Every Thought You Have Perhaps this is the deepest part of the practice. You are not every thought that passes through your mind. You don’t have to believe every thought. You don’t have to act on every thought. You don’t have to be frightened by every thought. Thoughts can come and go while you remain present enough to choose what you do next. And sometimes the most compassionate thing we can do is simply notice a difficult thought, acknowledge that it is there, and let it pass without building a home around it. You may not get to choose every thought that arrives. But you can practice choosing which ones you stay with. Notice. Name. Return. And then, gently, choose again. 🌿 curated for mindful living